“This
is a revolution of the hungry! … Egyptians have had
enough!”
Chaos
Escalates In Cairo Streets As A Truce Fails
By
Anthony Shadid (*)
From
Cairo
New
York Times, November 23, 2011
Cairo.–
The outskirts of Tahrir Square, the iconic landmark of
Egypt’s revolution, plunged into chaos on Wednesday, after
attempts by the Egyptian military, religious clerics and
doctors failed to stanch a fifth day of fighting that has
posed the greatest crisis to the country since the fall of
President Hosni Mubarak in February.
The
fighting in darkened streets, suffused with tear gas and
eerily illuminated by the flashing lights of police cars and
the floodlights of armored personnel carriers, seemed to
stand as a metaphor for a political transition that has
careened into deep uncertainty just days before elections
that were supposed to anchor the shift from military to
civilian rule.
The
military that seized power with Mr. Mubarak’s fall
rebuffed protesters’ demands to surrender authority this
week, and the political elite has seemed paralyzed or
defensive over the unrest. The discontent in Tahrir Square
has broadened from demands for the generals to cede control
and anger over bloodshed into dissatisfaction with a
transition that has delivered precious little since the
uprising’s heady days in February.
“This
is a revolution of the hungry!” declared Amr Ali Mohammed,
a 23-year-old protester taking a break from the battle with
the police. “Egyptians have had enough.”
The
sense of uncertainty that prevailed in Egypt echoed some of
the most anxious days of the uprising that began in January
against Mr. Mubarak’s nearly 30 years of rule. Though life
went on in much of the capital, the protests demonstrated a
resilience they had lacked for months, and episodes of
dissent have erupted in other parts of the country,
including Alexandria, Egypt’s second-largest city. Neither
politicians nor the military seemed ready to embrace a
drastic step that many insisted was needed to end the
unrest.
By
nightfall, crowds rivaled their size on past days, anchored
by a demand that has become the anthem since the crisis
began: the fall of Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi,
the de facto leader and longtime colleague of Mr. Mubarak.
In the square’s side streets, youths fought the police to
the backdrop of unending ambulance sirens.
“If
he leaves it like this and stays silent, it will be a
disaster,” said Suleiman Mahmoud, as he stood in a street
that looked like a symbol for urban distress — pools of
stagnant water strewn with rocks, shattered glass, trash and
fallen tree branches. “He’ll pay the price, and the
country will pay the price. Stubbornness is not a
solution.”
With
political leaders tentative, and signs that the military was
unable to exert control over the police, other voices
emerged in the country on Wednesday, demanding some kind of
action. Most important was the grand imam of Al Azhar, an
institution that is a prominent seat of religious
scholarship long co-opted by the government but now seeking
a more independent role.
The
grand imam, Sheik Ahmed al-Tayyeb, called on the police not
to fire on protesters, “no matter what the reason.” He
urged protesters to restrain themselves and demanded that
the military, whose relations with the Interior Ministry and
its loathed police forces have long been strained, do
everything it could to prevent more clashes.
“Al
Azhar reminds everybody that dialogue stained with blood is
doomed, and its fruit will be bitter in the throats of
everyone,” the cleric’s statement said.
His
warnings were echoed abroad, in a sign of growing
international concern over the crisis in the Arab world’s
most populous country. The French Foreign Ministry condemned
what it called “the excessive use of force against
demonstrators,” and Navi Pillay, the United Nations human
rights chief, called for an independent investigation into
the bloodshed, which has left 38 people dead and hundreds
wounded since it began Saturday.
A
sentiment pronounced often here has become a refrain of
sorts in moments of crisis: a foreign hand. With
parliamentary elections scheduled to begin on Monday, the
Muslim Brotherhood, the most powerful and well-organized
Islamic movement in Egypt, suggested in a statement on
Wednesday that “there has been a plan to create chaos,”
and Field Marshal Tantawi made the same contention in an
address to the country on Tuesday night.
Even
some onlookers at Wednesday’s events in the square
struggled to make sense of the turn of events.
“It
is in someone’s interest to benefit from the delay of
elections, I just don’t know who it is,” said Marwa
Hussein, 18, a student who visited the square for the first
time on Wednesday. “Someone is benefiting from this chaos.
We just don’t know who.”
The
protests began on Friday, and violence followed on Saturday.
At times, the crowds in Tahrir Square have seemed determined
to recapture the spirit of February, when hundreds of
thousands converged in downtown Cairo to press their demand
for Mr. Mubarak’s fall, to the backdrop of songs by
Abdel-Halim Hafez, a revered Egyptian singer. It was a
moment of unity that contrasted with the current state of
Egyptian politics, which fragmented soon after the military
seized control, and with a widespread sense that the
generals, with their opaque decision making, have horribly
mismanaged the transition.
But
Wednesday had a more martial feel, evident at the square’s
entrance. “Take care of yourself, captain,” said a
vendor selling surgical masks for an Egyptian pound (about
17 cents). On broad avenues cordoned off to evacuate the
wounded, youths sought to maintain order among crowds, as
motorcycles carrying as many as four sped by.
“Clear
the way!” men shouted. The square was suffused with
chants, sirens that blared through the night, vendors
hawking food, flags and scarves. At a cafe, men with goggles
and gas masks sat along the sidewalk, sipping tea and
smoking water pipes. “Live free, stay in the square,”
read the graffiti nearby.
“This
is only going to end when the military turns over power,”
said Dr. Mohammed Gilal, 28, who was treating patients in a
makeshift clinic, where volunteers carted in canisters of
oxygen and nurses treated wheezing protesters overwhelmed by
gas. Dr. Gilal said he had seen hundreds of wounded since he
arrived Sunday. “I’m not leaving unless they kill me
with my colleagues. We’re not going to accept any more
talk.”
Some
activists joked that the anger was so widespread and deep
among the protesters that their chants should be, “The
people want the fall of the coming president.”
By
afternoon, the military tried to separate the protesters
from the police, and they were joined by doctors and clerics
from Al Azhar, in their distinct gray robes and white and
red caps. The truce lasted about 90 minutes before a crack
was heard behind a building. Crowds surged, then moments
later, a round of tear gas canisters was fired.
Protesters
seemed especially enraged that it had been fired as some of
them prayed, and it was unclear whether the military was
exercising authority over the police. A prominent cleric,
Mazhar Shahin, whose mosque is in the square, blamed the
police.
“Ambush,”
someone cried. “The government withdrew and said ‘O.K.,
we have withdrawn,’ so we all went up to see it,” said
Islam Mohammed, 18, his head and forearm bandaged. “We
were praying, and they attacked us in the middle of the
prayer. ”
Clashes
escalated through the night, and the Ministry of Health said
500 people were injured in just two hours. Bonfires cast a
glow down darkened streets, where protesters retreated from
tear gas, stumbling over the debris of their days of melees.
“The turning point is coming soon,” said Mostafa Helmy,
a 55-year-old engineer.
(*) Liam Stack
and Dina Salah Amer contributed reporting.
After
Apology, Egypt’s Military Rejects Quick End
to Its Rule
By
Anthony Shadid, David D. Kirkpatrick and Alan Cowell (*)
New
York Times, November 24, 2011
Cairo.–
Egyptian generals offered an unusual apology on Thursday for
the killings of protesters in Tahrir Square, the iconic
landmark of the country’s revolution, but rejected the
demonstrators’ demands for an immediate end to military
rule.
As
violence around the square eased after five days of intense
clashes, the military also insisted that parliamentary
elections, scheduled for next Monday, would proceed as
planned.
“We
will not delay elections. This is the final word,” Gen.
Mamdouh Shaheen, a member of the ruling military council
told a news conference.
Maj.
Gen. Mukhtar el-Mallah, another council member, told the
news conference that the military would not relinquish power
because to do so would be “a betrayal of the trust placed
in our hands by the people.” Egyptians must focus on the
elections, he said, not on street protests.
“We
will not relinquish power because of a slogan-chanting
crowd,” he said, according to The Associated Press,
“Being in power is not a blessing. It is a curse. It’s a
very heavy responsibility.”
On
what had been the front line of the confrontation near the
square, army troops in black helmets and visors replaced the
police — reviled by many protesters — and a crane
lowered cement barricades behind a line of coiled barbed
wire to separate the protesters from the Interior Ministry
building, near the library of the American University in
Cairo.
“The
Supreme Council of the Armed Forces presents its regrets and
deep apologies for the deaths of martyrs from among
Egypt’s loyal sons during the recent events in Tahrir
Square,” two generals said in a statement on a Facebook
page. “The council also offers its condolences to the
families of the martyrs across Egypt.”
The
message struck an apparently conciliatory tone as the ruling
military commanders seek to defuse the crisis in time for
the elections. But thousands of people remained in Tahrir
Square, many demanding the ouster of Field Marshal Mohamed
Hussein Tantawi, the de facto leader and a longtime
colleague of the deposed former president, Hosni Mubarak.
News
reports quoting the state-owned Middle East News Agency said
the commanders’ message was issued in the names of Maj.
Gen. Mohammed Al-Assar and Maj. Gen. Mahmoud Hijazi, two
members of the ruling military council who are subordinate
to Field Marshal Tantawi.
Two
days ago, Field Marshal Tantawi went on television to
promise that presidential elections would be held in the
first half of next year. But he did not offer an apology for
the killings and his words did little to placate the
demonstrators.
A
semblance of calm returned to Tahrir Square on Thursday
morning after a night of some of the worst clashes since the
protests began. A haze of tear gas had receded and
protesters said clashes stopped early morning.
Crowds
still gathered in a street leading to the Interior Ministry,
but the cacophony of tear-gas rounds, chants, and the cries
of protesters ferrying the wounded had diminished. Vendors
did brisk business selling gas masks.
As
the lines separated, an army major sought to strike up a
dialogue with the protesters across the barricades. He
leaned his ear in, unable to hear over demonstrators
chanting: “The people want the fall of the field
marshal!”
On
another street leading to the Interior Ministry, security
forces strung a second coil of barbed wire, reinforcing the
protective cordon around the building. About 75 yards behind
the wire, a row of soldiers in helmets and shields formed up
in front of two armored personnel carriers.
So
intense have the tear-gas barrages been in the last few days
that the chemicals have mixed with the city’s ubiquitous
dust so that when the dust is kicked up, people start
coughing and sneezing.
“The
army can’t retake control of the square anymore,” said
Sherif Ibrahim, a high school teacher.
“It’s just not possible.”
Another
protester’s banner declared: “The army protects. It does
not rule.”
Facing
the lines of soldiers beyond the barbed wire, protesters
chanted slogans like “Leave” and “He who loves Egypt
won’t destroy Egypt.”
Throughout
the week of confrontation, the military that seized power
with Mr. Mubarak’s fall has rebuffed protesters’ demands
to surrender authority, and the political elite has seemed
paralyzed or on the defensive over the unrest. The
discontent in Tahrir Square has broadened from demands for
the generals to cede control and anger over bloodshed into
dissatisfaction with a transition that has delivered
precious little since the uprising’s heady days in
February.
By
mid-morning Thursday, news reports said, a shaky informal
truce appeared to be holding.
The
chaos on Wednesday posed the greatest crisis to the country
since the fall of President Mubarak in February, despite
efforts by the Egyptian military, religious clerics and
doctors to stanch a fifth day of fighting.
The
clashes in darkened streets, suffused with tear gas and
eerily illuminated by the flashing lights of police cars and
the floodlights of armored personnel carriers, seemed to
stand as a metaphor for a political transition that has
careened into deep uncertainty just days before elections
that were supposed to anchor the shift from military to
civilian rule.
The
sense of uncertainty that prevailed in Egypt echoed some of
the most anxious days of the uprising that began in January
against Mr. Mubarak’s nearly 30 years of rule. Though life
went on in much of the capital, the protests demonstrated a
resilience they had lacked for months, and episodes of
dissent have erupted in other parts of the country,
including Alexandria, Egypt’s second-largest city. Neither
politicians nor the military seemed ready to embrace a
drastic step that many insisted was needed to end the
unrest.
Crowds
were anchored by a demand that has become the anthem since
the crisis began: the fall of Field Marshal Tantawi. In the
square’s side streets, youths fought the police to the
backdrop of unending ambulance sirens.
“If
he leaves it like this and stays silent, it will be a
disaster,” said Suleiman Mahmoud, as he stood in a street
that looked like a symbol for urban distress — pools of
stagnant water strewn with rocks, shattered glass, trash and
fallen tree branches. “He’ll pay the price, and the
country will pay the price. Stubbornness is not a
solution.”
With
political leaders tentative, and signs that the military was
unable to exert control over the police, other voices
emerged in the country on Wednesday, demanding some kind of
action. Most important was the grand imam of Al Azhar, an
institution that is a prominent seat of religious
scholarship long co-opted by the government but now seeking
a more independent role.
The
grand imam, Sheik Ahmed al-Tayyeb, called on the police not
to fire on protesters, “no matter what the reason.” He
urged protesters to restrain themselves and demanded that
the military, whose relations with the Interior Ministry and
its loathed police forces have long been strained, do
everything it could to prevent more clashes.
“Al
Azhar reminds everybody that dialogue stained with blood is
doomed, and its fruit will be bitter in the throats of
everyone,” the cleric’s statement said.
His
warnings were echoed abroad, in a sign of growing
international concern over the crisis in the Arab world’s
most populous country. The French Foreign Ministry condemned
what it called “the excessive use of force against
demonstrators,” and Navi Pillay, the United Nations human
rights chief, called for an independent investigation into
the bloodshed, which has left 38 people dead and hundreds
wounded since it began Saturday.
(*) Anthony
Shadid and David D. Kirkpatrick reported from Cairo, and
Alan Cowell from Paris. Liam Stack and Dina Salah Amer
contributed reporting from Cairo.
|